Quest to Stop Dishwasher Drain Gurgling.....

[Sterob]

Our dishwasher makes very annoying noises ( as lots of other peoples do too ) when its running, as there is a direct line between the drain inlet and the sinks. Its like a pair of horns!

536498

I thought if I tapped into the drain line after the water seal(s) , that would solve our problem?
536499

Googling found lots of complaining but did not find anyone mention this as a solution......
It seems to make sense....have a water seal between the drain inlet and sink drains to stop the noise coming throught the sink!

Not sure if I would use two S bends or one at this stage....It depends on room under the sinks.
I can't think of any reason why this would not work. Am I missing something?

Can anyone definitvely say this will or will not work? Its alot of work finding fittings to discover I have been wasting my time....lol

Steve

[droog]

The trap on the drain stops gasses and smell escaping from the drain out of the fixture / appliance.

With your plan what stops the gasses and smell from escaping via the dishwasher ?

[Sterob]

The trap on the drain stops gasses and smell escaping from the drain out of the fixture / appliance.

With your plan what stops the gasses and smell from escaping via the dishwasher ?



Nothing......but this is why we ask.
I didn't realise THAT was the reason for using the S Bends.

Can that be cured or am I wasting my time?

[Wrongwayfirst]

Your question was will this work or not, I will say not. As per response above the design of the trap is to keep the open sewer smell out of the house.
how noisy is your dishwasher?? I not wish to sound harsh, but:U since dishwashers have been made they have connected them this way, early days the plumber would cut a hole in the side of the trap. Nowadays this is a moulded barb fitting. How old is your dishwasher??
given the number of dishwashers connected worldwide in this exact way if noise was an issue then why is there not more people looking to find a solution? My dishwasher makes noise but not enough to bother me.

[jack620]

I honestly can't see the sewer gasses working their way through the diswasher plumbing and drain pump. The sump in my D/W always has water in it too, so I assume that works as a trap.

However, with your proposed solution, I wonder whether the escaping dishwasher waste water might syphon out some of the sink trap water? The solution I use is to plug the sinks when the dishwasher is running. It almost completely eliminates the gurgling sounds when the dishwasher pumps out the water. We have the integrated plugs with waste baskets.

[Fuzzie]

I imagine if you plumbed it the suggested way it would actually siphon the water out of the s-bend when the dw ran. You would end up with both noise and smell.

[BobL]

My coffee machine waste is plumbed in after the sink S bend and there's no syphoning of water out of the S bend. OTOH the volume of waste water from the coffee machine is significantly less than from a dishwasher.

[capt'ngrumpy]

My coffee machine waste is plumbed in after the sink S bend and there's no syphoning of water out of the S bend. OTOH the volume of waste water from the coffee machine is significantly less than from a dishwasher.

Don't mean to burst your bubble Bob, but if there isn't a trap incorporated in the waste drain of the coffee machine, then technically this is not legal.
The waste from coffee machines is usually via gravity, not pumped.

Good practice for dishwasher waste connection would normally entail the pump hose to be affixed hard to underside of sink, creating a loop. This is quite often stipulated in the installation instructions from some manufacturers.

,

[rambunctious]

Don't mean to burst your bubble Bob, but if there isn't a trap incorporated in the waste drain of the coffee machine, then technically this is not legal.
The waste from coffee machines is usually via gravity, not pumped.

Good practice for dishwasher waste connection would normally entail the pump hose to be affixed hard to underside of sink, creating a loop. This is quite often stipulated in the installation instructions from some manufacturers.

,
Re coffee machine.
Correct, the waste should not be connected directly to any plumbing and should in fact be stopped above a trap and draining into a tundish, in turn creating an air gap as required by law and in turn stopping cross connection.

Re dishwasher.
Again correct.
Connection can be made direct to a sink trap, or to a separate trap, but same as coffee machine, with an air gap to stop siphonage.
The bowl above a sink trap acts as an air gap
For the purpose of fixing the hose high up the machine is usually supplied with a plastic U fitting approx 100mm+ in dia, which, when inverted, becomes the holding fitting for the loop.
Having installed a lot of dishwashers I have never seen a machine not supplied with the U fitting.
I have however been called to find out why water was still being left in the dishwasher and it was usually because the hose was too low and allowing water to drain back into the machine, often when the sink was flushed and even worse when a garbage disposal unit was installed in the opposite bowl.

[capt'ngrumpy]

Re coffee machine.
Correct, the waste should not be connected directly to any plumbing and should in fact be stopped above a trap and draining into a tundish, in turn creating an air gap as required by law and in turn stopping cross connection.

Re dishwasher.
Again correct.
Connection can be made direct to a sink trap, or to a separate trap, but same as coffee machine, with an air gap to stop siphonage.
The bowl above a sink trap acts as an air gap
For the purpose of fixing the hose high up the machine is usually supplied with a plastic U fitting approx 100mm+ in dia, which, when inverted, becomes the holding fitting for the loop.
Having installed a lot of dishwashers I have never seen a machine not supplied with the U fitting.
I have however been called to find out why water was still being left in the dishwasher and it was usually because the hose was too low and allowing water to drain back into the machine, often when the sink was flushed and even worse when a garbage disposal unit was installed in the opposite bowl.

I don't believe it to be practicable for an air gap when connecting a dishwasher or clothes washing machine to a trapped standing wastepipe. The likelihood of siphonage is fairly negligible unless the hose is placed to deep in the pipe.There was a time where a coupled connection was applied, but I think this is now an outdated method.

[mic-d]

I don't believe it to be practicable for an air gap when connecting a dishwasher or clothes washing machine to a trapped standing wastepipe. The likelihood of siphonage is fairly negligible unless the hose is placed to deep in the pipe.There was a time where a coupled connection was applied, but I think this is now an outdated method.

the trap with a barb/barbs has an extended vertical section above the trap where the barbs are located. Clearance is built in the design.

[capt'ngrumpy]

the trap with a barb/barbs has an extended vertical section above the trap where the barbs are located. Clearance is built in the design.

Sorry. Fail to see your point. Talking about seperate connection to a standing waste, ie. dropping the drain hose into top of a 40 or 50mm vertical pipe, where the trap is at the base.

[capt'ngrumpy]

Our dishwasher makes very annoying noises ( as lots of other peoples do too ) when its running, as there is a direct line between the drain inlet and the sinks. Its like a pair of horns!

536498

I thought if I tapped into the drain line after the water seal(s) , that would solve our problem?
536499

Googling found lots of complaining but did not find anyone mention this as a solution......
It seems to make sense....have a water seal between the drain inlet and sink drains to stop the noise coming throught the sink!

Not sure if I would use two S bends or one at this stage....It depends on room under the sinks.
I can't think of any reason why this would not work. Am I missing something?

Can anyone definitvely say this will or will not work? Its alot of work finding fittings to discover I have been wasting my time....lol

Steve
You could substitute the 's' trap for a double nippled combination trap (available from bunnings) and connect the dishwasher hose to the lower nipple. This would displace the flow from dishwasher to below the weir of the trap and possibly soften if not nullify the gurgling noise. Provided the hose is looped to underside of the sink as previously mentioned, I don't see any problems with this approach.

[droog]

I am not a plumber so you would have to confirm rules but I do not believe there is anything stopping you plumbing the dishwasher drain into a separate trapped connection. You may need this topped with an air admittance valve above the trap or there may be nothing stopping you from leaving it open.

Check with your plumber first.

Another option that may improve the situation is a remote trap further away from the sinks:
PK945 Spazio Plumbing Kit 3B (https://www.franke.com/au/en/home-solutions/products/accessories/product-detail-page.html/112.0058.945.html)
This also improves under sink storage in most cases.

[rambunctious]

I don't believe it to be practicable for an air gap when connecting a dishwasher or clothes washing machine to a trapped standing wastepipe. The likelihood of siphonage is fairly negligible unless the hose is placed to deep in the pipe.There was a time where a coupled connection was applied, but I think this is now an outdated method.

What you believe and the AU Standards are 2 totally different things.
A coupled connection (totally sealed) causes siphonage where as a tundish is allowing air to be admitted to the pipe/trap as required in the Au Standards.
Of course you can hook the WM/DW drain pipe into the waste pipe as long as it finishes above the trap seal, that is a given.
The air gap is created by the fact the waste pipe is 40-50mm whereas the drain pipe from WM/DW is 25mm give or take.
FWIW there is a lot more to plumbing than asking the lady at Bunnings what you need then screwing/gluing a few pipes and fittings together.

[capt'ngrumpy]

What you believe and the AU Standards are 2 totally different things.
A coupled connection (totally sealed) causes siphonage where as a tundish is allowing air to be admitted to the pipe/trap as required in the Au Standards.
Of course you can hook the WM/DW drain pipe into the waste pipe as long as it finishes above the trap seal, that is a given.
The air gap is created by the fact the waste pipe is 40-50mm whereas the drain pipe from WM/DW is 25mm give or take.
FWIW there is a lot more to plumbing than asking the lady at Bunnings what you need then screwing/gluing a few pipes and fittings together.

FYI the outdated method I refer to was a coupled connection to a 40mm, or larger, trapped standing-wastepipe. This comprised of a barbed fitting screwed into bush with holes drilled in it, to prevent being totally sealed.
It is not often that a diswasher is discharged above a tundish. Especially in a domestic installation.
The legal height of air gap for a discharge pipe above a tundish is 25mm.
Then again you would know this.
I find your comment of the asking the lady from bunnings quite insulting.

[BobL]

Don't mean to burst your bubble Bob, but if there isn't a trap incorporated in the waste drain of the coffee machine, then technically this is not legal.
The waste from coffee machines is usually via gravity, not pumped.

For many years I had the coffee machine drain connected to just above the sink trap using a 2.5m length of hose (red line). The hose went through a hole in the bench top and followed a very shallow (5º) run behind the dishwasher to the sink cupboard - the shallowness of this run repeatedly blocked this hose by the small amounts of coffee grounds over time settling out. This was at times a nightmare to unblock and I even had to occasionally use compressed air to unblock the drain hose.

536552

When I got my new coffee machine I connected the drain to a 1.5m long 20 mm Black poly which dropped through the same hole in the bench top, and then vertically down through a kitchen cupboard and wooden floor n (purple line), into the basement under the kitchen. Here there is a 20 mm black poly right angle bend connected in turn to a 2.5m length of black poly that slopes at an angle of about 30º down to and connects to the sink waste line under the kitchen. With this degree of vertical drop the grounds are easily carried to waste even by the small amounts of drain water output by the coffee machine.

I realize none of this is probably "legal" but it works, no blockages and no discernible smell.

[capt'ngrumpy]

As long as you're happy with it Bob, I ain't telling anyone.

[Sterob]

Your question was will this work or not, I will say not. As per response above the design of the trap is to keep the open sewer smell out of the house.
how noisy is your dishwasher?? I not wish to sound harsh, but:U since dishwashers have been made they have connected them this way, early days the plumber would cut a hole in the side of the trap. Nowadays this is a moulded barb fitting. How old is your dishwasher??
given the number of dishwashers connected worldwide in this exact way if noise was an issue then why is there not more people looking to find a solution? My dishwasher makes noise but not enough to bother me.


Its very noisy. The dishwasher is new ( Bosch) and I've had 2 plumbers look at it, with no joy. I have the molded barb, that you mention.
The home is open plan with the kitchen and family room together. The gurgling, we can hear over the tv.....:U

[Sterob]

I honestly can't see the sewer gasses working their way through the diswasher plumbing and drain pump. The sump in my D/W always has water in it too, so I assume that works as a trap.

However, with your proposed solution, I wonder whether the escaping dishwasher waste water might syphon out some of the sink trap water? The solution I use is to plug the sinks when the dishwasher is running. It almost completely eliminates the gurgling sounds when the dishwasher pumps out the water. We have the integrated plugs with waste baskets.

Yes, plugging the holes does dampen the noise but SWMBO does not want to do that......

[Sterob]

My coffee machine waste is plumbed in after the sink S bend and there's no syphoning of water out of the S bend. OTOH the volume of waste water from the coffee machine is significantly less than from a dishwasher.


Thanks Bob....interesting.

[Sterob]

I've had another thought.....
What if I add 2 more P Traps under both bowls?

It complicates the pipework, but It apears to solve both problems.
Fumes and DW noise.

Thoughts?

Steve

536553

[capt'ngrumpy]

I've had another thought.....
What if I add 2 more P Traps under both bowls?

It complicates the pipework, but It apears to solve both problems.
Fumes and DW noise.

Thoughts?

Steve

536553
Do not do this. Double trapping is an absolute no no. Gee 2 plumbers with no results. What tests did they carry out?
1- check the nipple/barb on trap is clear and has been drilled out to the total bore.
2- check the hose hasn't been squashed or kinked. This may involve pulling the d/w unit out completely.
3- check the impeller on the pump in base of d/w if possible, for foreign objects.
4- consider contacting the supplier/manufacturer , you may have a lemon.

[Sterob]

Do not do this. Double trapping is an absolute no no. Gee 2 plumbers with no results. What tests did they carry out?
1- check the nipple/barb on trap is clear and has been drilled out to the total bore.
2- check the hose hasn't been squashed or kinked. This may involve pulling the d/w unit out completely.
3- check the impeller on the pump in base of d/w if possible, for foreign objects.
4- consider contacting the supplier/manufacturer , you may have a lemon.


Ok...thanks. I won't do this.

[r3nov8or]

Yes, plugging the holes does dampen the noise but SWMBO does not want to do that......

Well, that's her problem. :)

We've always had the gurgling since the kitchen reno and went with dual sinks. Two different DWs, same thing. We have solar, so we run the DW during the day when there is usually no-one hanging around or watching TV.

[jack620]

Well, that's her problem.

I thought the same thing, but wasn’t brave enough to say it! I mean, it’s a free solution and it works.

Steve, show your wife this thread. :)

[rwbuild]

For many years I had the coffee machine drain connected to just above the sink trap using a 2.5m length of hose (red line). The hose went through a hole in the bench top and followed a very shallow (5º) run behind the dishwasher to the sink cupboard - the shallowness of this run repeatedly blocked this hose by the small amounts of coffee grounds over time settling out. This was at times a nightmare to unblock and I even had to occasionally use compressed air to unblock the drain hose.

536552

When I got my new coffee machine I connected the drain to a 1.5m long 20 mm Black poly which dropped through the same hole in the bench top, and then vertically down through a kitchen cupboard and wooden floor n (purple line), into the basement under the kitchen. Here there is a 20 mm black poly right angle bend connected in turn to a 2.5m length of black poly that slopes at an angle of about 30º down to and connects to the sink waste line under the kitchen. With this degree of vertical drop the grounds are easily carried to waste even by the small amounts of drain water output by the coffee machine.

I realize none of this is probably "legal" but it works, no blockages and no discernible smell.

That is illegal if there is no s trap at the point of connection. Nothing to stop vermin (cockroaches) from travelling up it regardless of how often you use and flush it but more importantly the bacteria that breeds in any black or grey water drain will eventually contaminate your machine especially if your are away from home for an extended time ie: holidays, medical problems.

[BobL]

That is illegal if there is no s trap at the point of connection. Nothing to stop vermin (cockroaches) from travelling up it regardless of how often you use and flush it but more importantly the bacteria that breeds in any black or grey water drain will eventually contaminate your machine especially if your are away from home for an extended time ie: holidays, medical problems.

The bacteria is likely to be the least of my worries compared to the 5-6 double shots of espresso I have daily. :oo:

[mic-d]

The bacteria is likely to be the least of my worries compared to the 5-6 double shots of espresso I have daily. :oo:

:o:o Bob, how many grams of coffee are in those double shots? The boss has until recently had 2 x 22g shots a day but cut back to one.

[Sterob]

Well, that's her problem. :)

We've always had the gurgling since the kitchen reno and went with dual sinks. Two different DWs, same thing. We have solar, so we run the DW during the day when there is usually no-one hanging around or watching TV.


Actually, its 'our' problem......

- - - Updated - - -


I thought the same thing, but wasn’t brave enough to say it! I mean, it’s a free solution and it works.

Steve, show your wife this thread. :)


Not A Chance....lol

[r3nov8or]

Actually, its 'our' problem......


You could do one plug each; share the load :)